The day Elvin Jones fired up Milwaukee’s Lakefront Festival of Art in 1972


elvin (3)

Dave Liebman turns up the heat with a soprano sax solo with bassist Gene Perla and bandleader Elvin Jones accompanying. Saxman Steve Grossman lays out in the background. Photo by Kevin Lynch at the 1972 Lakefront Festival of Art. 

This blog is a birthday remembrance, honoring — one month late to the day — the monumental jazz drummer and innovator Elvin Jones, who was born on September 9, 1927 in Pontiac, MI, and died May 18, 2004. His passing prompted the original version of this appreciation, published in 2004 in The Capital Times Rhythm section, aptly enough. Now, the photo-essay aspect was also prompted by Racine trumpeter Jamie Breiwick’s assiduous recent efforts at building an archive of Milwaukee jazz history, here: – KL.

Elvin Jones has driven the jazz spirit in my mind and body since before I knew it. Besides countless jazz drummers, he’d influenced the double-drummer approach of The Grateful Dead and The Allman Brothers Band, and the Coltranesque dramatic flow of the Butterfield Blues Band’s pioneering instrumental epic “East-West” of 1966, which he praised with a sage sense of the musical zeitgeist. 1

I had already caught the Coltrane bug, and Jones’ drumming coursed though my veins as I followed Trane’s incandescent, rhythmically refracted quest.

Jones’ innovative drumming style boiled all the implications of a time signature into rolling accents and a sliding pulse that pulled the listener in, and freed the music with a balance of sly sophistication and muscular resonance. As the most integral member of the classic John Coltrane Quartet, Jones went somewhat underappreciated by wide audiences after he left that group. This was partly because his approach was baffling to many even as you heard and felt its effectiveness and power to carry and lift the music.

Some drummers picked up on his triplet-figured rhythmic attack and started approximating his ambidextrous polyrhythms, which created a unique dynamic tension across the drum kit while requiring a loose-limbed bodily execution. (Jones succinctly describes his polyrhythms as “many rhythms, coordinated rhythms”) But few could capture the essence of his marvelous motion. That included monstrous press rolls to rival Art Blakey’s and a roaring sonic totality when swinging alongside a saxophonist as inspired as Trane in full locomotion.

At times you could hear Jones grunting and groaning as he played, and those bodily exhalations seemed integral to his sense of rhythmic dynamic and propulsion, like a tai chi martial artist. The analogy came to mind not because I know he had knowledge of, or had studied, that artful discipline. But I know he was married to a Japanese woman, Keiko Jones, who also wrote music, sometimes for her husband’s group.

elvin band

I recall hearing (and meeting Elvin and Keiko) in 1972 at Milwaukee’s Lakefront Festival of Art, which was the occasion of the photos I took, which you see on this blog. I was with one of my best friends, Frank Stemper, then a local jazz pianist who would soon become a composer, earning a PhD. in music (on which I collaborated with him on his final project) and becoming the long-time director of the University of Southern Illinois– Carbondale music department. Frank’s compositions have been performed worldwide, he has a sophisticated sense of musical time and was a big Buddy Rich fan. And yet, that day, intently watching and listening to Elvin, Frank finally exclaimed, “What is he doing?!” (More on that concert later.) 2

elvin 3

Clockwise from top left: (1) Elvin Jones played so powerfully that he had to nail a board to the stage to keep his bass drum from moving. (2) He chats with a fan while pounding. (3, and above) His quartet essays an ensemble section and (4) the quartet is framed by the lovely setting of the 1972 Lakefront Festival of Art in Milwaukee’s Juneau Park, on Lake Michigan. 

Racine-born, Wisconsin Conservatory of Music-trained bassist Gerald Cannon,  who has played with many world-class jazz artists, commented “I was the last bassist to play with Elvin Jones. I was with the (Elvin Jones) Jazz Machine for about seven years, and I thought I knew how to play the bass before I played with Elvin. I was wrong. I learned more about dynamics, time, groove, and melody from Elvin than any band I had ever played with before him. I really learned to trust myself and my time with him. He was a great man. I miss him dearly. God Bless Elvin Jones.” 3

Indeed, Jones had evolved into a sui generis master musician with an ensemble concept which he developed in a series of superb albums on the Blue Note label. He showed that his post-Coltrane jazz would be diverse and subtle, but swinging and declamatory, and need not be deathly serious in manner.

Sadly a number of these albums remain un-reissued on CD. 4. So I don’t hesitate recommending wholeheartedly The Complete Elvin Jones Blue Note Sessions on the limited-edition label Mosaic Records ($128, mail order only at 203-327-7111 or, an investment that is rewarding, pleasurable and a deep slice of obscured music from modern jazz’s greatest drummer. A debilitating arm injury prompted me to listen to the whole 8-CD set recently, but each album is worth savoring.

Jones’ wizardly multi-directional motion filled the rhythmic role of piano accompaniment and his coloristic approach to drum tones and savvy bassist Jimmy Garrison and reed player Joe Farrell provided a remarkably rich trio sound in his early Blue Note sessions “Puttin’ It Together” and “The Ultimate.” Farrell, who died in 1986 at 49, was a resourceful master of saxes and flutes, and would not be fully appreciated until his later work with pianist Chick Corea.

Farrell was a consistently delightful and inventive musical thinker on these dates. Jones expanded his ensemble on the albums Coalition and Genesis and especially on one of my favorite jazz albums of the 1970s, Merry-Go-Round. The date included the masterful baritone saxophonist Pepper Adams, ex-Basie tenor player Frank Foster and two young fiery Coltrane sax disciples, Dave Liebman and Steve Grossman. Merry-Go-Round had a carnivalesque variety and bristling joi de vivre, and among its highlights are Corea playing on the first recording of his small masterpiece of Latin jazz, “La Fiesta,” Liebman’s exultant hard swinger “Brite Piece” and bassist Gene Perla’s sassy strutter “’Round Town.”

elvin 4

Clockwise from top left: (1) With Elvin Jones at the drums, Dave Liebman solos on tenor sax, (2) then soprano sax. (3) Fellow saxman Steve Grossman tears it up (with bassist Gene Perla driving the pulse), and (4) finally Elvin Jones takes a drum solo.

I got a live earful of this great material at that unforgettable Lakefront Festival of Art performance. I also recall, near the stage, my dad Norm Lynch, a big jazz buff, hoisting my young sister Anne up on his shoulders, so she could better see and hear the fiery and sometimes blistering music. That muscular double-sax quartet (with Liebman, Grossman and bassist Perla) would soon produce an explosive multi-disc set called Live at the Lighthouse which is  intact in the Mosaic collection as an edgy, thrilling exposition of the band’s creative power. Throughout this mighty box set, Jones’ flaming, indefatigable musicality illuminates lyrical chamber trios, Latin-style percussion jams, octets and expansive live sets.

Still, it’s worth remembering, Elvin Jones came of age with John Coltrane, so to fully understand, or at least experience, him one must hear that body of work, largely available on Atlantic and Impulse Records.

“With John, everything I had learned up to that point, it gave it significance,” Jones recalls of the classic John Coltrane Quartet, with pianist McCoy Tyner and bassist Garrison. 5  Having descended from the mountainous vistas of Coltrane’s spiritual expedition, Jones brought his own music somewhat more down to earth, wind and fire. And yet he could still take you on a journey that you can take nowhere else.


All photos by Kevin Lynch. This article was originally published in shorter form in The Capital Times in 2004.

NOTE: One of the first women to break into the upper ranks of modern jazz was Marian McPartland. The pianist and her trio (pictured below), opened for Elvin Jones that day in Milwaukee. McPartland would later go on to host a popular NPR jazz radio program where pianists would visit her live in the studio, discuss their music and play live solos and duets with Marian.

Marian Mc

  1. Elvin Jones — upon hearing Mike Bloomfield’s long and highly influential composition “East-West” on the Butterfield Blues album East-West — commented, in part: “Very well done. This has a nice feeling. I’d give that five stars.” – Down Beat Blindfold Test, Nov. 17, 1966.
  2. Perhaps the best elucidation of Jones and his innovative percussion approach is on the video documentary Elvin Jones: Different Drummer. It includes Jones’ own vivid and eloquent descriptions of his style and its effects, which was a multi-color-related concept, as he explains it. A technically superior document of Jones in extended performance is the DVD Elvin Jones: Jazz Machine from a 1991 concert.
  3. Gerald Cannon posted his remembrance of Jones on the comments section for the Different Drummer You Tube (see link in footnote 2).
  4. Check the online All Music Guide for comments on availability of individual albums:
  5. The Elvin Jones quotes in this article are from the documentary film Different Drummer.

8 thoughts on “The day Elvin Jones fired up Milwaukee’s Lakefront Festival of Art in 1972

  1. Wonderful article. I got the Elvin Jones bug when I was a 15 year old guitarist living in Seattle. Several of the guys in my blues/rock band were into jazz and played me some Coltrane records with Elvin. When I moved to the East coast I saw Elvin many times with this band. I was honored to play and record with Elvin . A great man..

  2. thank you for the article on elvin. 2 stories: I heard him, in toronto in the early 70’s with joe farrell at an afternoon session. I was sitting towards the back of the club when farrell began a long obligato solo that led into my ship. when I heard theopening notes of the song I opened my eyes and elvin was looking straight at me and grinning. the last time I heard him was in the late 70’s in los angeles at marla’s memory lane. after the set he walked straight up to me and shook my hand. two points about the article: 1. keiko is Japanese not Chinese and elvin didn’t nail his drums to the floor, he nailed a board to the floor to keep his bass drum from traveling.

    • George, Thanks for the good comments and the clarifications. I met Elvin and Keiko at this event and they graciously posed with me for a photo that I can’t yet locate. KL

  3. Hi, Kevin – I had the honor of playing with Elvin Jones at a Gretsch Drum Night at Lennie’s on the Turnpike in Peabody, MA c. 1967. Also performing were Alan Dawson and Jimmy Cobb. I was in the house band at Lennie’s at that time with a quintet. I remember a kid in the front row holding Elvin’s bass drum on the low stage. At one point, Elvin gave me a cigar which he had lit and had gone out. I kept that cigar in my bedroom drawer until it was dust. It was an amazing and unforgettable experience. I also knew his bassist, Gene Perla, in Boston when Gene was a pianist and just beginning to play bass, mid-60’s. I spent some time in Gene’s basement apartment on Newbury Street, Boston, where he had a grand piano and used to copy Bill Evans’ voicings from the LPs (as many of us did). ;>)

    • Wow, Mr. Velleman those are some heady memories and experiences! Interesting that it also included Alan Dawson and Jimmy Cobb. Was it some sort of drummers’ round-robin, Battle Royale, cutting contest?
      You should’ve covered or secured the cigar is something airtight to preserve it, like plastic so you could show it off as well (Easy for me to say). I have a clump of dirt from the batters box from which Cecil Cooper hit the pennant-winning base hit for the Milwaukee Brewers in 1982. I also have the tip of the drumstick of the great blues drummer Sam Lay (Muddy Waters, Paul Butterfield etc.) which once flew off a rimshot virtually right to my feet. But in the pantheon of artifacts none of those quite compares with your Elvin cigar.
      Ha, the kid held the drum so it wouldn’t walk away! I didn’t realize Perla was a pianist but it’s unsurprising. And of course as the saying goes “Everybody Digs Bill Evans.”
      Thanks for the memories, my friend,

Leave a Reply to keve2109Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.